Op/Ed
Opinion: Looking for the modern tipping point
The 250th anniversary of our Declaration of Independence is fast approaching. What was the tipping point that turned colonists into rebels and protest into violent revolution?
Historians cite Britain’s 1773 passage of the Tea Act as a major turning point leading to rebellion. The Tea Act reinforced the principle that Britain’s Parliament could tax the colonists even though they had no representatives in Parliament (“taxation without representation”). Others contend the tipping point came in 1774 with the passage of the Coercive Acts (called the “Intolerable Acts” by the colonists) resulting in:
- Closing the port of Boston;
- The Massachusetts Government Act, that replaced elected officials with appointees of King George III and restricted town meetings;
- Allowed British officials accused of crimes committed while enforcing the Massachusetts Government Act to be tried in another colony or in England enabling officials to escape justice; and
- The Quartering Act, raising fears that British troops would be housed in private homes against the will of homeowners.
Colonists became convinced that Britain intended to rule the colonies without their consent, self-government was under direct threat, and peaceful protest was unlikely to succeed in altering these circumstances. On April 19, 1775, the battles at Lexington and Concord transformed political resistance into revolution.
The Tea Act (i.e., “taxation without representation”) resembles Trump’s tariffs. They have been established without Congressional approval (our representatives), causing higher prices that like a tax have been passed on to us and business owners.
The Coercive Acts are analogous to Trump’s threats to freeze or withhold federal funding from states, cities and universities; and/or ordering the Department of Justice to file lawsuits against law firms, media companies and other institutions that resist administration policies (e.g., eliminating Diversity, Equity, Inclusion practices and curtailing free speech).
The Massachusetts Government Act that reduced self-government by shifting power to officials appointed by King George III and helped them avoid prosecution, is like Trump’s control over federal agencies via his political appointments; restricting the independence of career civil servants or replacing them with loyalists; punishing those who oppose Trump with lawsuits, and pardoning individuals convicted of fraud and public corruption.
There are no equivalents to the Quartering Act. But parallels may be drawn to Trump’s deployment of federal law-enforcement to states and cities to enforce immigration policies over the objections of citizens and their locally elected leaders and control civil unrest.
Severe harm, suffering, and deaths have accrued from the actions of Trump and his minions. His inattention to the economic pain being experienced by millions; the wanton and obscene corruption he engages in to fill his own pockets and those of his family; his trillion-dollar debacle in Iran; and his increasingly brazen attempts to alter the outcome of the 2026 midterms detrimentally affects us all!
On June 24th Trump cancelled his signing of the 21st Century Road to Housing Act, a major affordability package for which there was overwhelming bipartisan support. He’s holding Americans hostage who desperately need housing until Congress passes the SAVE Act. A bill to unconstitutionally usurp state control of elections by establishing nationwide requirements for voter registration and voting in federal elections. Trump has begun saying that failure to pass the SAVE Act would constitute a “national emergency.” A phrase I believe we’ll hear him mouth more often as we get closer to the 2026 mid-terms.
State and District Federal courts have tried to hold the line. Often their decisions are ignored, bastardizing the rule of law. Acting Attorney General, Todd Blanche, recently refused US District Judge Leonie Brinkema’s order to provide sworn declarations stating that the 1.7-billion-dollar “weaponization” fund would not proceed “in any manner, or under any name.” Money that could be used to fund a private army of Trump loyalists.
Political and social reality in 2026 America is grim! We are led by a racist, narcissistic, megalomaniac who has little to lose that he values. What will be our tipping point? If and when it is reached, will it be too late as it was in 1934-1936 Nazi Germany when Chancellor, Adolph Hitler eliminated opposition parties, legal actions failed, coercive institutions expanded, fear and surveillance became pervasive, and the police state became fully operational?
Ron Rubin
Middlebury
More News
Op/Ed
Editorial: A barn-raising, mayhem, and land as community
“For much of this rainy June I’ve been out-of-state on family affairs … What I didn’t mi … (read more)
Op/Ed
Community Forum: Don’t wait till later to talk about school funding
“Vermont voters and taxpayers will have the final say, and they don’t have enough informat … (read more)
Op/Ed
Ways of Seeing: The Purple Gazebo
The Purple gazebo was built over one hundred years ago for an orphanage in Shelburne.









