Deadline flexible for district merger study
BRISTOL — The ANWSD-MAUSD Merger Study Committee is not obligated to finish its work in time to warn a possible vote on Town Meeting Day, March 1, 2022, and the committee made a point of repeating this fact several times during its second meeting on Aug. 17.
“March isn’t the definite end point,” educational consultant Tracy Wrend told the committee, which met in the Mount Abraham Union High School cafeteria. “It’s up to you to decide.”
The Merger Study Committee was formed in April by the boards of the Addison Northwest School District (serving Addison, Ferrisburgh, Panton, Vergennes and Waltham) and the Mount Abraham Unified School District (serving Bristol, Lincoln, Monkton, New Haven and Starksboro) to “analyze the advisability of forming a union school district.”
The 15-member committee consists of six ANWSD residents and nine MAUSD residents.
Their official charge suggests it would be “ideal” if they completed their work in time to allow for a Town Meeting Day vote, but this is not required.
That timeline is “ambitious,” Wrend said at the meeting.
The Merger Study Committee made a point of clarifying their deadline flexibility in part because some MAUSD residents, including school board members, have expressed concerns about the committee’s authority and schedule, suggesting that holding a potential merger vote on Town Meeting Day would lock their district into a process that would make it impossible to give fair consideration to the five community-authored long-range facilities plans now on the table in the MAUSD. None of those plans explicitly favors a merger with the ANWSD.
Some residents of Lincoln and Starksboro also worry that the MAUSD articles of agreement prohibiting school closure without voter approval from the town hosting that school would be overwritten by the Merger Study Committee.
That and other concerns have prompted a movement in Lincoln to withdraw from the MAUSD, and residents cast votes on that question on Tuesday (See story on Page 1A).
The Merger Study Committee has hired Wrend to help guide its work.
She served as the Superintendent of the Lamoille South Unified Union from 2007 to 2021 and has facilitated multiple merger studies, according to her bio.
Wrend opened her remarks last week by congratulating the committee for undertaking its work.
“From my observation point — I’m a little outside of this region — you are a leader in future thinking about your schools, and I believe it’s super-important to engage in that work, even though it’s really hard,” she said. Whatever unfolds over the next several months, it will not only help the districts improve outcomes for students, she continued, but it will also provide “the groundwork that allows schools, school systems and communities to pivot quickly and be nimble in times of challenge.”
Wrend shared with the committee an example workplan illustrating what would need to get done, and when, to wrap up by March, but the plan includes blank meeting dates that could be filled in through Election Day on Nov. 8.
For a rundown of the workplan Wrend proposed, see the online version of this story at https://tinyurl.com/ANW-MAU.
The Study Committee must first develop a hypothetical merger scenario, including articles of agreement, then decide if that merger is advisable.
If the committee decides it’s advisable to create a merged entity, it must write a report and submit it to the Agency of Education and to the ANWSD and MAUSD boards. If it advises against merging the committee may still create a report if it wants.
Every report Wrend has facilitated has included a narrative and rationale, including pros and cons of the committee’s recommendations, even if the committee advised against merging, she said. And all of that work ended up being “hugely valuable,” regardless of recommendation outcomes, she added.
There’s no statute that explicitly requires the Study Committee to seek school board approval for a potential merger proposal, but any such plan would have to pass muster with the State Board of Education.
If that happens, the merger plan could then be presented to the voters.
Any proposed merger must be approved by a majority of ANWSD voters and also by a majority of MAUSD voters. If the proposal fails to win a majority of votes in either district, the proposal fails, according to Vermont statute.
At this time it is believed that votes would be commingled among ANWSD’s five communities and would be separately commingled among the MAUSD’s five towns.
THE SHORT VERSION
“So our job, first of all, is to figure out the best possible proposal for a merger … and then to decide if we want that?” asked Erica Andrus, a committee member from Ferrisburgh.
Yes, Wrend said. “You have to have a model of something to evaluate the pros and cons of in order to compare it … So there is a delicate balance (in) creating something that you may not believe right now is a good idea. You almost need to suspend disbelief for a little bit and create the best thing you can. At the same time you’re evaluating pros and cons in relation to the values, criteria and the goals that you think are important for making your decision.”
The Merger Study Committee next meets on Tuesday, Aug. 31, and then on Tuesday, Sept. 21, with locations to be announced. Beginning in October the committee will meet on the first Monday and third Tuesday of each month.
All meetings will begin at 6:30 p.m.
Reach Christopher Ross at [email protected]
Ferrisburgh selectboard reorganizes
The Ferrisburgh selectboard on March 21 elected Clark Hinsdale as its new chair in the boa … (read more)
Lincoln news for Mar. 30
Prizes and treats are up for grabs at the United Church of Lincoln’s annual Easter Egg Hun … (read more)
With climate changing, it’s time to electrify our homes
After a winter short on snow, and a maple sugaring season that started in January, the big … (read more)