Ways of Seeing by Claire Corkins: Did cutting tree really benefit town?

Our silver maple tree was cut down. We didn’t want to cut it down. It wasn’t dying. The choice, however, was taken out of our hands because this particular tree was growing in that thin strip of grass between sidewalk and street. That land you have to mow but the town controls.
The silver maple was old. At least 80 years old according to the memories of my father, who remembers it being there, quite big, when he was a child. I can only tell you about its last 35 years, the time I spent with it.
I remember it as always being huge, too big to wrap my arms around. It had large patches of peeling bark covered in green lichen that we would collect to make fairy houses. Its green leaves had silvery backs that made the leaves look shiny when they rustled in the wind. It was hard to mow around because it was up on a little hummock.
When I was a kid we would lose badminton birdies in its canopy. Our solution of course was to throw the rackets up into the branches to dislodge it. Sometimes the rackets got stuck — and more rackets were employed until the tree at last released our birdie.
Over time a few branches died. After heavy windstorms there would always be some branches littering the lawn under the tree. But every year in the spring it would be renewed, a huge green canopy.
Its roots slowly rose in the lawn, causing more stubbed bare toes in summer and making mowing more difficult. And the sidewalk slowly rose as the roots grew under it, making either an awesome bike jump or a tripping hazard, depending on your position. It was that way for years and years. All my life.
Then the town decided to replace the sidewalks. They did not see the uneven cement as an awesome bike jump. They decided the tree had to go. A smooth sidewalk was more important.
I came home for lunch one day in September to see my majestic old friend lying in pieces, being cut down. The harsh sounds of a chainsaw filled the air. Men in Carhartts were chipping branches or moving logs. One man, suspended with his chainsaw by ropes, cut. I couldn’t watch.
They got rid of the branches but left the logs, stacked up in a pile by the road. Passersby commented. They wondered why — the tree had looked healthy. They commiserated.
We saved a few of the logs — a project for later. And then the rest were taken by a neighbor and the stump was ground and the tree was completely gone; just an empty space left. They put the new sidewalk in.
It has been several weeks, but I still see an empty space every time I look at where the tree used to be. It still takes me by surprise when I come around the corner or look out the window, expecting to see green leaves and instead see the neighbors’ houses.
My daughter declared this had been her favorite tree. She made a RIP sign for it. She shed tears for it. Even the prospect of a replacement tree held no appeal.
I wonder if the loss of the tree affects me so much because I like old things. I like record players and wooden windows, I like reading real books and writing with pencil on paper. Perhaps it is just nostalgia — a link to my childhood. Or maybe I just like trees better than cement.
Perfectly smooth, wide sidewalks are great, but what really makes a walk on a summer’s day pleasant? Big old shade trees. They are what make old towns walkable and gives them their character. If we continue to cut down all the big old trees to the benefit of our sidewalks, we will not increase the walkability of our town.
I continue to receive condolences for the tree. Flowers, thoughts, leaf tracings. I have not received a single compliment on how nice and flat the new sidewalk is.
Claire Corkins grew up and lives in Bristol. After studying Human Ecology at College of the Atlantic in Maine, she worked abroad teaching English as a second language. She currently works with her father in such various endeavors as painting houses, tiling bathrooms, building porches and fixing old windows. She hikes, reads, plays ice hockey, travels and wishes she could wear flip-flops all year round.

Share this story:

More News

Bernard D. Kimball, 76, of Middlebury

MIDDLEBURY — Bernard D. Kimball, 76, passed away in Bennington Hospital on Jan. 10, 2023. … (read more)

News Uncategorized

Fresh Air Fund youths returning to county

The Fresh Air Fund, initiated in 1877 to give kids from New York City the opportunity to e … (read more)

Obituaries Uncategorized

Mark A. Nelson of Bristol

BRISTOL — A memorial service for Mark A. Nelson of Bristol will be held 1 p.m. on Saturday … (read more)

Share this story: