MIDDLEBURY — Middlebury residents on Jan. 26 will be asked to approve — for the first time in 54 years — a major overhaul of their municipality’s town charter, a 265-year-old document that essentially serves as the community’s constitution, delineating the rules by which its town government operates.
Some of the proposed changes to the foundational document involve cleaning up language and making it more contemporary; after all, the current Middlebury charter doesn’t acknowledge the internet, nor a selectboard that has grown from five to seven members.
But some of the recommended tweaks will definitely be noticed, if they earn local approval on Jan. 26 and then final endorsement by the state Legislature and Gov. Phil Scott this winter. For example, one of the charter revisions would allow the town to raise its highest possible fine from the current $1,000 to $10,000 per offense. Another tweak would pave the way for the community to allow any person — rather than just a local resident — to apply for committee vacancies.
Selectman Fred Dunnington chaired the Middlebury Charter Review Committee, formed by the selectboard in May 2025 to recommend changes to the document.
“The charge was to update, not fundamentally redesign, our town charter, to reflect current practices,” Dunnington stressed in a recent report to the board.
Middlebury has made four small amendments to its charter since 1972. Those successful amendments allowed Middlebury to create its Downtown Improvement District, its Local Option Tax, and pursue appointment (rather than election) of its auditor and treasurer.
But a major overhaul was needed this time, led by the Charter Review Committee. That body, according to Dunnington, approached its review with a commitment of maintaining the rights of local voters; preserving the annual town meeting, community engagement and transparency; and “maintaining our robust, professional town management structure and roles.”
The Charter Review Committee — which also included selectboard members Andy Hooper and Isabel Gogarty — met around 10 times to receive and discuss charter-change feedback. The panel submitted proposed changes to the selectboard, which held two public hearings to receive additional testimony. The selectboard on Oct. 27 warned a special meeting for a Jan. 26 Australian ballot vote on the 77 specific proposed charter amendments, which can be found at tinyurl.com/2v2xhpe7.
Read further for some specific examples of the proposed charter changes, but town officials want you to know the amendments are aimed at seven principles:
• Updating the processes by which residents participate in town governance.
• Clarifying and updating how the selectboard carries out its responsibilities.
• Updating outdated language, while removing provisions that no longer reflect current practices.
• Clarifying what the town has authority to regulate, while updating how ordinances are adopted and enforced.
• Defining the town manager’s employment terms more clearly, adjusting the balance of authority between the manager and the selectboard to reflect current practices.
• Updating how town positions are filled, along with eligibility to serve on municipal boards and committees.
• Transparency & Public Information — Modernizing transparency and public information requirements, from printed notices and library posting, to online access through the town’s website.
Here are some of the specific charter-change proposals:
• Reducing the time for an adopted municipal ordinance to take effect, from the current 40 days to 14 days. Voters would still have the right to petition in opposition to a proposed ordinance.
• Allowing any person, rather than just registered town voters, to apply for appointment to committee vacancies.
This doesn’t mean that committees and commissions will suddenly be dominated by folks from outside of town. The Middlebury Downtown Improvement District Commission as a current example of a local panel that includes some non-residents. The DIDC includes members who own property and/or business in the core village area, but who might live in other towns.
“It’s still our expectation, all things being equal, to draw people who live locally and have actively participated locally,” Dunnington said.
• Requiring that the town manager be appointed by contract, and no longer for an indefinite time period.
• Noting the town must adopt ethics policies and procedures for all boards/officers/employees, per state law.
• Clarifying that selectboard members have the right to attend and speak at other town board and committee meetings, including their executive sessions.
What about the proposed raising of the cap on municipal fines from $1,000 to $10,000?
Dunnington explained that part of the reasoning is inflation.
“$1,000 was a lot of money in 1972,” he said.
Now — not so much, at least when it comes to punishment for major infractions, such as the deposit of a large amount of environmentally damaging sludge at the town’s wastewater treatment plant.
“In a really egregious case, we’d want to have an ordinance and an ability to fine someone seriously if they did something in a repeated way that cost (the town) a lot of money,” Dunnington said. “We’d also want to be able to recoup our costs.”
He acknowledged that cases of the town assessing a maximum-amount fine have been “exceedingly rare” in Middlebury’s history.
Plans originally called for the vote on the charter changes to take place during the Nov. 3 elections. But officials decided the referendum deserved its own vote, given the number of charter changes being requested and the already crowded midterms ballot.
“I believe this is an election that deserves to have a lot of people look at (the proposed changes), with an opportunity to vote early if they want to, rather than standing in the voting booth and looking through all of this,” Dunnington said.
John Flowers is at [email protected].
